Shop owner in Navan wins cigarette case against HSE
The official took away two packets of Silk Cut cigarettes worth €36.90 for laboratory testing by the State Laboratory for levels of carbon monoxide, nicotine and tar.
16 November 2026
The owner of a small newsagent’s shop in Navan has won a landmark court case against the Health Service Executive (HSE) over the price of two packets of cigarettes.
An authorised official of the HSE had called to the ‘Just a Thought’ newsagent’s owned by Philip Keegan at Johnstown Shopping Centre in the town in June 2025.
The official took away two packets of Silk Cut cigarettes worth €36.90 for laboratory testing by the State Laboratory for levels of carbon monoxide, nicotine and tar.
The official reportedly gave the shop assistant a receipt for the cigarettes but no money was handed over.
Mr Keegan has been trying to extract payment from the HSE since June last year without success.
The HSE allegedly said it could not pay him the money on “fiscal rectitude” grounds.
Mr Keegan’s solicitor Gerry McGrath claimed in court that the goods had been taken by the HSE without lawful authority.
Navan District Court was told that negotiations between the two sides since a previous court hearing in October had not resulted in agreement and a full hearing of the case went ahead today.
Judge Éirinn McKiernan granted a decree for €36.90 to Mr Keegan along with legal costs of €1,500.
Vincent Jennings, CEO for the Convenience Stores and Newsagents Association of which Mr Keegan is a former president, said that the HSE had “improperly seized” the cigarettes for testing.
He said the law explicitly provided for the payment of tobacco products taken by an authorised officer.
The case had been fought over two days attended by a barrister, two solicitors, the principal officer of the Tobacco Control section and two staff.
Congratulating Mr Keegan for “sticking to his principles”, Mr Jennings said there were several opportunities for the HSE to pay Mr Keegan but instead had “squandered” up to €10,000 of public funds in a “wasteful manner.”
Article credits: Navan shop owner wins cigarettes case against HSE
Read more: CSNA advises businesses to beware of cyberattacks and insurance cover



Print




Followers 0
Fans 0
Followers